Overall,
most people enjoyed the book. I’d say about four stars on average. Almost
everyone mentioned that they had heard about this book their whole lives, but
never got around to reading it until now, which was interesting because that
was one of the reasons I was excited to read this book. One person even
mentioned how they wished it still was a required novel in schools. Another
mentioned how impressed they were that Abraham Lincoln himself praised the
book.
From Goodreads.com, Tammy King Carlton, 12 August, 2008: “This book is one of the most moving, provocative pieces of literature I've ever read, and it's the first time that I can recall being moved to tears from a book. As long as I live, I will never be able to remove from my mind the vision of Eliza, panicked and frenzied, in the dead of the night with her baby boy in her arms, leaping across the frozen ice of the Ohio river to escape the trader her baby had been sold to. And if anyone wants to read a profound and well written narrative for the view of a Black Slave, look to George's monologue on page 127-128, where he is at the Inn with Mr. Wilson, disguised as a white upper-class gentlemen, and explaining to Mr. Wilson how he feels about his country. I was involved in the book up to that point, but after that, this book owned me. This should be required reading of every American Citizen, and it's in my top five of the most important books I have ever read. For whatever the cause of the American people, it all comes down to "When in the course of human events...".”
From Goodreads.com, Tammy King Carlton, 12 August, 2008: “This book is one of the most moving, provocative pieces of literature I've ever read, and it's the first time that I can recall being moved to tears from a book. As long as I live, I will never be able to remove from my mind the vision of Eliza, panicked and frenzied, in the dead of the night with her baby boy in her arms, leaping across the frozen ice of the Ohio river to escape the trader her baby had been sold to. And if anyone wants to read a profound and well written narrative for the view of a Black Slave, look to George's monologue on page 127-128, where he is at the Inn with Mr. Wilson, disguised as a white upper-class gentlemen, and explaining to Mr. Wilson how he feels about his country. I was involved in the book up to that point, but after that, this book owned me. This should be required reading of every American Citizen, and it's in my top five of the most important books I have ever read. For whatever the cause of the American people, it all comes down to "When in the course of human events...".”
I agree very
much with this comment from Good Reads because I also found George’s monologue
to Mr. Wilson very moving, and a defining point in the novel. It gave a very
clear, and deep insight to the life of a slave, and many points of it were
relatable, to some degree. Although, I did not cry while reading this book.
From BarnsandNoble.com:
“When I started to read this book, I was crying as the characters were separating.
Harriet Beecher Stowe wrote this novel in such a fantastic way that I could
actually bond and understand what the characters had to go through. Although
most of this book is very sad and depressing, she ties it together with more
fortunate events which make the novel seem even more real. I think that Harriet
Beecher Stowe is one of the only authors who understands that one novel can not
just be only morbid or gleeful, and that if you tie those two feelings together
(with some more feelings to one side than another to set the tone), more
connection and passion can be felt by the reader. Once you read this fantastic
novel, you will be amazed at the real connection you feel with the characters
and actual slaves.”
Again, I did
not cry while reading this book. Other than that I also very much so agree with
this comment as well because for me, when I read books, an important factor
that helps me really ‘get in to it’ is when there’s relatable characters. And I’m
sure that a lot of other people can agree with that. And the part about the
novel being not only morbid and not only gleeful is a good observation that I
had not noticed before, that there are some happy moments in the novel.
From
Amazon.com, Michael B. Grant, July 7, 2014: “I have heard about this book my
whole life but never understood what it was about. If, like me, you make the
assumption that it is a book about a slave that "sells out his own
race", which is the definition of Uncle Tom that I gathered by looking at
television and hearing the term used, you will surely miss the entire point of
this book. Instead, the book is about a slave that is steadfast in his beliefs
and principles. A man that holds on to his faith in Jesus. I really don't get
the common use of the term after reading this. Every one should read this book.
It can be a hard read as it is a glimpse into a dark period in history.”
This comment
is an interesting one, because I had never heard of the term “Uncle Tom”
described as a man who “sells out his own race”. But Michael B. Grant is definitely
right about how it is a hard read in the sense because it is so dark. It gave
me such a close look in to slavery, at times it was quite shocking. As a senior
in high school, when we first read about what it was like to be on a slave
boat, was the first time I truly captured how horrifying slavery really was.
Out of the three readers you mentioned, I found Michael B Grant's response to be the most relatable. Similar to Grant, I had heard of the novel throughout my life but never knew the full extent of the story. As you pointed out, he mentions that a slave who "sells out his whole race" is an "Uncle Tom." Before reading Grant's comment I had never hear of this association before. I think it's really interesting to see how different types of readers and their backgrounds influence the way the book is perceived before, during, and after reading. Personally, I wouldn't have seen anything wrong with the phrase "Uncle Tom," but those who have regional ties to it may be more likely to recognize the context of the novel.
ReplyDelete