For this blog post, I will focus on the theme of gender, in A Streetcar Named Desire, by Tennessee
Williams. “[The “Blue Piano” goes softly.
She turns confusedly and makes a faint gesture. The inhuman jungle voices rise
up. He takes a step toward her, biting his tongue which protrudes between his
lips.]” (Williams, 1170).
In this novel, we see may scenes of
abuse and patriarchy involved with Stanley. On page 1125 Stanley says to Stella,
“How about my supper, huh? I’m not going to no Galatoire’s for supper!”. Even
after she tells him that she made him a “cold plate on ice” he gives a
sarcastic reply back. He’s not grateful for all that she does for him already,
and can’t let Stella have one night alone with her sister, whom she was only
taking out to dinner to be out of their way while Stanley had his poker game,
which in my opinion, was a nice thought to avoid conflict, but of course there
is still a problem with Stanley.
The scene I want to mostly analyze
though, is the one where Stanley rapes Blanche. First of all, it’s incredible
messed up that Stanley even wants to have sex with his wife’s sister, another
complete disregard for Stella’s feelings. Not to mention that Stella is also
pregnant with his child. Also, Blanche is clearly unstable. She has many
underlying issues with her deceased husband and the affairs she had after his
death. Anyone with some type of heart, would probably avoid raping someone like
that. You should probably avoid raping someone in any sort of manner though.
One could argue though, that with
Blanche’s past with her seventeen-year-old lover, and countless others, that
she may have been open to having sexual relations with Stanley. But in my
opinion, I think Blanche is uneasy about Stanley, as we see in their first
meeting, “[drawing involuntarily back
from his stare] You must be Stanley, I’m Blanche.” (1124).
In consideration to Stanley’s
personality, “[Branching out from this
complete and satisfying center are all the auxiliary channels of his life, such
as his heartiness with men, his appreciation of rough humor, his love of good
drink and food and games, his car, his radio, everything that is his, that
bears his emblem of the gaudy seed-bearer. He sizes women up at a glance, with
sexual classifications, crude images flashing into his mind and determining
that way he smiles at them.]” (1124) one can clearly see what kind of man
Stanley is. He diminishes women based on how they can sexually please him, and
that then determines how he treats a woman. I do think it’s interesting though
how he victimizes himself, “’Pig-Polack-disgusting-vulgar-greasy!’- them kind
of words have been on your tongue and your sister’s too much around here!”
(1160) for having to endure racial slurs from Stella and Blanche, but they have
to put up with all of his disrespect towards them.
The gender roles in this play are very clear. Stanley
expects complete respect from Stella, and Blanche now that she is living with
them, with no consideration of how he treats them, and their feelings. Stanley’s
whole reason in the play as to why he doesn’t like Blanche is because of her “shady past” but has no problem contributing to the reason of why she is unfit to be
married.
I'm glad you focused on the theme of gender and, in particular, sexual assault. Do you think that Williams creates complex characters who are all suffering from some kind of oppression? Like, Stanley feels oppressed because of ehtnic slurs and class-based oppression, and then uses the power he has a man to really put both Stella and Blanche in their places? There is interesting research that suggests that rape and other forms of sexual assault are primarily about power over sexual pleasure and desire. How does Williams complicate this issue?
ReplyDeleteI do agree that Stanley definitely uses his remorse about his ethnicity, and channels that into the way he treats Stella and Blanche. Your comment about how sexual assault is more about power than sexual pleasure and desire reminds me of how in Elementary School they would tell us that bullies really felt bad about themselves and that's why they bullied people. It's kind of like that but obviously more harsh. I also think Williams complicated this issue by throwing in the twist that Blanche is Stella's sister, and the fact too that Stella has a baby on the way. It's really sick that Stanley is able to get his way in things by playing on other's vulnerabilities.
DeleteI chose the same theme of genders and gender roles throughout the play and I do agree with your analysis of Stanley. He's so disrespectful to Stella, Blanche, and almost everyone during the play. Even though he seems to victimize himself, do you think that he actually believes it and that's why he's such a terrible person? That doesn't make anything he did right, but some men are hypersensitive to certain things and personally I think Stanley's manhood was put into question by Stella because her prior life was so influential and of a higher class which was a part of his acting out and need to control everything.
ReplyDeleteI definitely agree that Stealla's previous life proabaly provoked him to be more violent, especially since now in the household he was "outnumbered".
DeleteThe scene that you chose to analyze was definitely a hard scene to read through just because of the fact that sexual assault is so apparent in our society today and many don't know how to reach out for help. The other part that was interesting to read in your blog post was your connection through patriarchy and why Stanley mistreats Blanche.
ReplyDelete